Related Articles
- Modernists in Exile: Three Portraits of a Lost Generation
- A Lost Generation in Motion: Hemingway and Whitehead
- A Moveable Self: Hemingway’s Memoir of Love, Loss, and Literary Becoming
- Twilight of Illusions: A Processual Study of Tender Is the Night
- The Last Tycoon: Fitzgerald’s Final Vision of Power, Romance, and the American Machine
I. Publication & Historical Context
📅 1. Publication Overview
-
Title: The Sun Also Rises
-
Author: Ernest Hemingway
-
First published: 1926 by Charles Scribner’s Sons
-
Original draft title: Fiesta (still used in many European editions)
-
Critical reception: Acclaimed for its stark realism and stylistic innovation; controversial for its cynical tone, drinking culture, and depiction of aimless youth
This novel marked Hemingway’s first full-length novel, following his short story collection In Our Time (1925). It immediately established him as a central voice of the “Lost Generation” and a major innovator in modernist fiction.
🌍 2. Historical and Cultural Background
➤ Post-World War I Europe
The novel takes place in the wake of the First World War, a conflict that had devastated much of Europe and deeply scarred a generation of young men. For many of these veterans, the old moral codes—of religion, honor, patriotism, and love—had lost their meaning.
-
Hemingway himself was wounded as a Red Cross ambulance driver in Italy.
-
Many young Americans, including Hemingway, became expatriates, disillusioned with the materialism and conformity of the United States.
-
Paris in the 1920s became a haven for artists, writers, and thinkers who found creative freedom abroad.
This cultural phenomenon was famously labeled by Gertrude Stein as the Lost Generation, a term Hemingway used as the novel’s epigraph:
“You are all a lost generation.”
➤ The Expatriate Movement
The Sun Also Rises captures this expatriate subculture with intimate detail: Americans and Britons drinking in Paris cafés, discussing art and love, traveling through Spain, and constantly searching—for meaning, for distraction, for themselves.
-
The novel’s characters are modeled after real figures in Hemingway’s own social circle, many of whom traveled with him to Pamplona in 1925 to see the bullfights.
-
The expatriate life is portrayed as both glamorous and tragic—full of pleasure and spontaneity, but also drifting and emotionally numb.
🗡️ 3. Literary Modernism
The Sun Also Rises is a landmark modernist novel in form and content:
-
It rejects Victorian narrative conventions, emotional melodrama, and moral certainty.
-
Instead, it embraces fragmentation, ambiguous morality, understatement, and psychological realism.
-
Hemingway’s clipped dialogue and sparse narration mirror the emotional restraint and detachment of his characters.
This is a novel written after belief collapses, and its form reflects that collapse. Yet, paradoxically, the story reaches for moments of beauty, intensity, and ritual—fishing, bullfighting, drinking, walking alone at sunrise—that suggest the resilience of experience even when ideals are broken.
🕰️ 4. Biblical and Cyclical Time
The title comes from Ecclesiastes 1:5:
“The sun also ariseth, and the sun goeth down, and hasteth to his place where he arose.”
This verse evokes a cosmic cycle that continues despite human suffering. In this context, Hemingway suggests that even in the aftermath of war and personal ruin, life persists. The sun still rises. There is no salvation, perhaps—but there is continuity, process, and endurance.
📌 Summary
The Sun Also Rises emerges at the intersection of:
-
A disillusioned generation seeking to rebuild their lives
-
A postwar Europe haunted by absence and moral erosion
-
A modernist literary revolution that broke with past forms to find new truths in fragments
In this world, Hemingway writes not to redeem the old, but to name what is left—and to honor what remains in the human will to feel, to love, to endure.
III. Main Characters
Each character in The Sun Also Rises embodies a fractured identity shaped by war, loss, and longing. They are not archetypes but processual beings—struggling to define themselves in relation to each other, to their memories, and to the culture around them. Hemingway strips away sentimentality and lets their contradictions surface through behavior and clipped dialogue.
🧍♂️ Jake Barnes
Role: Narrator and protagonistOccupation: American journalist in Paris
Wound: Physically (likely emasculated by war injury), emotionally (in love with Brett but cannot consummate it)
Jake is the novel’s still center. He observes more than he acts, feels deeply but rarely expresses it. His emotional restraint, war-inflicted impotence, and stoic demeanor reflect Hemingway’s “grace under pressure” ideal. He is both drawn to and alienated by the world he inhabits.
-
His love for Brett is sincere, tender, and doomed.
-
He provides emotional and financial support to nearly everyone, yet rarely receives it in return.
-
He respects Romero because Romero represents the unity of form and purpose that Jake longs for.
-
In many ways, Jake is a metaphor for modern man—injured, rootless, yearning for intensity in a world of disillusionment.
“I can’t stand it to think my life is going so fast and I’m not really living it.”
👒 Lady Brett Ashley
Role: The novel’s emotional and romantic center
Status: Divorced Englishwoman, engaged to Mike Campbell, lover of several men in the novel
Character arc: Passionate, magnetic, but emotionally restless and self-sabotaging
Brett is iconic—a literary embodiment of the “New Woman” of the 1920s. She drinks, smokes, moves freely among men, and refuses to conform to traditional gender roles. Yet beneath her fierce independence is a woman wounded by war, broken love, and internalized instability.
-
She loves Jake but cannot reconcile love with his injury.
-
She seeks affirmation in male desire but pushes away intimacy.
-
Her allure is destructive; her freedom comes at the cost of stability.
“You know it makes one feel rather good deciding not to be a bitch.”
Brett is not a villain. She’s a modern woman trapped in a world where no one—man or woman—knows how to love anymore.
✍️ Robert Cohn
Role: Outsider, romantic idealist, former boxer
Background: Jewish-American Princeton graduate; not a veteran
Cohn represents an anachronistic idealism that grates on the rest of the group. He believes in true love, heroic passion, and moral clarity—but in a postwar world where everyone else is fractured, Cohn’s certainty becomes irritating, even threatening.
-
He falls obsessively for Brett and becomes jealous and violent.
-
He cannot cope with ambiguity or rejection.
-
Though he seems “soft,” he is physically powerful and becomes aggressive when emotionally cornered.
“You can't get away from yourself by moving from one place to another.”
Cohn becomes a scapegoat for the group’s own buried emotional confusion. He is excluded for believing too much, in a world where everyone else believes too little.
🗣️ Bill Gorton
Role: Jake’s closest male friend
Traits: Witty, intelligent, emotionally balanced, provides comic relief
Bill is one of the few characters who maintains a degree of emotional coherence. He’s a companion on the fishing trip—a rare space of peace—and provides a contrast to Jake’s restraint with his humor and verbal flamboyance.
-
His joking masks insight.
-
He’s loyal, but less wounded than the others.
“You’re an expatriate. You’ve lost touch with the soil.”
Bill anchors Jake without demanding anything from him. He’s a processual friend—flexible, responsive, non-destructive.
🥃 Mike Campbell
Role: Brett’s fiancé; Scottish aristocrat turned bankrupt drunk
Traits: Bitter, insecure, drunkenly sarcastic
Mike embodies the decay of aristocratic masculinity. Once wealthy and dignified, he is now a hollowed-out figure propped up by alcohol and cynical jabs.
-
He loves Brett but cannot control her.
-
His drunken rants reveal pain masked as cruelty.
-
His financial ruin mirrors his moral unraveling.
Mike is what happens when old social roles persist but can no longer hold meaning.
🐂 Pedro Romero
Role: Young Spanish bullfighter
Symbolism: Embodiment of purity, beauty, tradition, and intensity
Romero enters late in the novel but quickly becomes its moral and aesthetic center. He represents the unbroken form—someone who acts with precision, discipline, and inner purpose.
-
His bullfighting is described as ritual art, not sport.
-
He attracts Brett not because he flatters her, but because he lives with style and integrity.
-
He is the novel’s counterpoint to emotional chaos.
Jake reveres Romero because he is what Hemingway wished modern life could be—committed, elegant, courageous, and whole.
🧠 Group Dynamic Summary
| Character | Embodies... | Represents... |
|---|---|---|
| Jake Barnes | Stoic longing + emotional restraint | Injured modern man, Hemingway surrogate |
| Brett Ashley | Desire, instability, and broken freedom | Postwar femininity in crisis |
| Robert Cohn | Idealism turned obsession | Outsider unable to adapt |
| Bill Gorton | Humor, resilience, good-natured realism | Grounded male friendship |
| Mike Campbell | Collapse masked by sarcasm | Failed aristocracy |
| Pedro Romero | Purity, dignity, unbroken form | Hemingway’s aesthetic ideal |
IV. Major Themes
1. Disillusionment and Emptiness
At its core, The Sun Also Rises is a novel about emotional depletion in the aftermath of a cultural and moral collapse. The trauma of World War I is rarely discussed directly, but it shapes every character’s worldview. The war has robbed them not just of ideals but of the ability to feel in coherent or lasting ways.
-
Jake’s impotence becomes a symbol of metaphysical impotence—a world that can no longer consummate meaning or love.
-
Conversation is full of evasions and silences; actions (drinking, traveling, fighting) replace introspection.
-
The group lives in perpetual motion, yet they go nowhere spiritually or emotionally.
“It is awfully easy to be hard-boiled about everything in the daytime, but at night it is another thing.”
2. Exile and Rootlessness
The characters are all displaced—geographically, emotionally, culturally. They are foreigners in Europe and strangers to themselves.
-
Paris represents cosmopolitan stimulation but also moral drift.
-
Spain offers ritual and beauty but ultimately cannot transform them.
-
Their identities are not anchored by nation, religion, family, or purpose.
This is not only physical exile—it is ontological. Jake and his circle are unmoored selves, unable to attach themselves to anything lasting.
3. The Crisis of Masculinity
Masculinity is a central theme—and it is always under threat or in transition.
-
Jake’s war injury renders him sexually impotent.
-
Cohn’s masculinity is mocked for being too sentimental or reactive.
-
Mike is emasculated by financial ruin and his inability to control Brett.
-
Pedro Romero, the bullfighter, stands alone as a model of pure, composed, performative masculinity—the only one in the novel who does not apologize for his power.
Hemingway explores the postwar reconstruction of manhood—what happens when heroism is no longer possible and dominance is no longer dignified.
4. Unfulfilled Love and Emotional Disconnection
Jake and Brett’s love is perhaps the most tragic element of the novel—not because it is thwarted by society, but because it is inherently impossible.
-
Brett cannot be with Jake due to his injury, but she also cannot stay with any man.
-
Her restlessness mirrors Jake’s restraint—they orbit each other, unable to land.
-
Other relationships in the novel are equally unsatisfying: shallow, transactional, or volatile.
Love, in Hemingway’s world, is not redemptive. It is an ache without resolution, a memory of something that might have been.
5. Ritual, Art, and Bullfighting as Meaning
One of the novel’s most profound insights is that ritual—especially aesthetic ritual—offers a temporary but authentic alternative to moral collapse.
-
Bullfighting is not presented as barbarism, but as an art form: precise, ordered, full of purpose and intensity.
-
Fishing becomes a brief return to peace and clarity.
-
Watching, not acting, becomes a way of experiencing truth for characters like Jake.
Romero is not just a bullfighter—he is a symbol of metaphysical integration: body and mind, beauty and danger, performance and substance.
6. The Persistence of Time / The Cycle of Life
Despite the novel’s emotional bleakness, its title—The Sun Also Rises—offers a muted hope. Drawn from Ecclesiastes, it suggests that:
-
Even in despair, the cosmos continues.
-
Human meaning may collapse, but time does not.
-
There is something sacred in survival, even if healing remains out of reach.
In a process-theological reading, this might be seen as a quiet affirmation that life remains in motion, and motion itself is meaningful.
🧠 Thematic Table Summary
| Theme | How It's Shown | Philosophical Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Disillusionment | Fragmented lives, lack of hope, emotional numbness | Collapse of ideals post-WWI; end of grand narratives |
| Rootlessness | Expatriate wandering, cultural displacement | Ontological exile; loss of grounding |
| Masculinity in Crisis | Jake’s impotence, Cohn’s volatility, Mike’s bitterness | Deconstruction of heroic manhood; fragile identity |
| Unfulfilled Love | Jake and Brett’s doomed romance; serial lovers | Love without resolution; absence of relational fulfillment |
| Ritual as Redemption | Bullfighting, fishing, travel as sacred rhythm | Aesthetic form replacing lost religious/moral form |
| Time and Endurance | “The sun also rises,” Jake’s quiet resilience | Processual becoming despite loss; survival as metaphysical grace |
V. Hemingway’s Style: The Iceberg Theory
❄️ The Iceberg Theory Explained
Ernest Hemingway developed what he called the “Iceberg Theory” of writing, also known as the theory of omission. In his own words (from Death in the Afternoon):
“If a writer of prose knows enough of what he is writing about he may omit things that he knows and the reader, if the writer is writing truly enough, will have a feeling of those things as strongly as though the writer had stated them.”
Hemingway believed that truth in fiction lies beneath the surface—just as the bulk of an iceberg remains unseen beneath water. The writer should reveal only what is necessary, letting the reader feel the weight of what is unsaid.
This minimalist style became Hemingway’s literary signature—and in The Sun Also Rises, it achieves full expression.
✍️ Key Elements of Hemingway’s Iceberg Style
| Stylistic Element | Description | Example from the Novel |
|---|---|---|
| Minimalist Prose | Short, declarative sentences; spare descriptions | “We ate well and cheaply and drank well and cheaply and slept well.” |
| Understated Emotion | Characters rarely articulate deep feelings directly | Jake never explicitly grieves his impotence or failed love |
| Omission as Depth | Emotional and narrative gaps invite interpretation | Jake and Brett’s relationship is defined by what they don’t say |
| Terse Dialogue | Simple, quick exchanges, often ironic or circular | “Would you do that?” / “I’d do anything for you. Would you do that for me?” |
| Objective Reporting | Narration is often observational, not introspective | Jake describes bullfights or Brett’s beauty without moral judgment |
🧠 Philosophical Depth Behind the Surface
Hemingway’s style is not merely about aesthetics—it reflects a postwar metaphysics of restraint. In a world where language has been cheapened by propaganda and sentimentality, Hemingway seeks authenticity through omission.
-
To speak less is to feel more truthfully.
-
The unsaid is not absence—it is presence held in tension.
In a Whiteheadian sense, Hemingway’s narration enacts prehension: the narrator gathers emotional, sensory, and historical data but does not fully verbalize it. The reader is invited to experience concrescence—assembling feeling and understanding internally, rather than being told how to feel.
🌀 Narrative Detachment and Emotional Intensity
Jake’s tone is detached but not numb. His descriptions are observational, even journalistic, but they often carry emotional weight precisely because they lack embellishment. For example:
“I was a little drunk. Not drunk in any positive sense but just enough to be careless.”
This line doesn’t explain Jake’s grief - it embodies it through tone, rhythm, and understatement.
Similarly, the bullfighting scenes are described with clinical precision—but their beauty and terror are felt viscerally. Hemingway does not editorialize—he curates reality, allowing the reader to undergo the emotional process without interference.
🛠️ Function of Style in the Novel
| Function | Example |
|---|---|
| Express trauma without sentiment | Jake never discusses the war directly, but his behavior reveals its impact |
| Reveal character indirectly | Brett’s restlessness is never explained, only enacted through decisions |
| Create space for interpretation | Cohn’s breakdown, Mike’s sarcasm, Brett’s flight—never justified, only observed |
| Mirror existential uncertainty | The sparse narration matches the emotional sparseness of the characters |
🧩 Aesthetic Summary
| Trait | Description |
|---|---|
| Clarity | Language is clean, unornamented |
| Silence | Omissions carry more weight than declarations |
| Compression | Much meaning is compressed into short, quiet statements |
| Emotional discipline | No indulgence, but subtle vulnerability beneath the surface |
| Ritual observation | Detailed attention to physical ritual (drinking, fishing, bullfighting) |
🖋️ Legacy
Hemingway’s style in The Sun Also Rises changed American prose. It:
-
Defined modernist realism for a generation
-
Influenced writers like Raymond Carver, Joan Didion, and Cormac McCarthy
-
Embodied the aesthetic of brokenness and endurance that typifies the Lost Generation
VI. Real-Life Inspirations (Roman à Clef)
🪞What is a Roman à Clef?
A roman à clef (French for “novel with a key”) is a work of fiction that is thinly veiled autobiography. Real people appear under fictional names, often with only slight disguise. Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises is a classic example—so closely based on actual people and events that many in the literary world immediately recognized the parallels upon its release.
🗺️ Origins of the Story: Pamplona, 1925
In July 1925, Hemingway took a trip to Pamplona, Spain, to attend the Festival of San Fermín and witness the bullfights. He went with a group of American and British expatriates, all tangled in personal and romantic tensions.
After the trip, he quickly wrote The Sun Also Rises, modeling nearly every major character after someone he had traveled with. This was not simply adaptation—it was literary transmutation. Hemingway turned lived chaos into artistic form, rendering his companions as emotional archetypes of modernist malaise.
🎭 Character Mapping: Fiction to Reality
| Fictional Character | Real-Life Inspiration | Relationship / Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Jake Barnes | Ernest Hemingway | The narrator; shares Hemingway’s job, war wound, temperament |
| Lady Brett Ashley | Lady Duff Twysden | British aristocrat; charismatic, sexually liberated, tragic allure |
| Robert Cohn | Harold Loeb | Jewish-American writer; pursued Duff/Brett obsessively |
| Mike Campbell | Pat Guthrie | Twysden’s fiancé; alcoholic, bitter, financially troubled |
| Bill Gorton | Donald Ogden Stewart | Humorist, screenwriter, close friend of Hemingway |
| Pedro Romero | Actual young bullfighter | Possibly inspired by Cayetano Ordóñez, a famed torero of the era |
These portrayals caused controversy—Loeb, in particular, felt exposed and humiliated, as his fictional counterpart, Cohn, becomes a symbol of weakness, obsession, and exclusion.
✍️ Why Did Hemingway Do It?
Hemingway’s roman à clef serves several purposes:
-
Emotional ProcessingHe wrote the novel almost immediately after the Pamplona trip. It reads like an exorcism of confusion, jealousy, and bitterness—particularly toward Duff Twysden and Harold Loeb.
-
Modernist ExperimentationRather than invent plot or character, Hemingway engages in a kind of documentary fiction—a strategy that reflects the modernist commitment to truth through direct experience, even if selectively filtered.
-
Critique of Self and OthersHemingway is not gentle with any of the characters—not even Jake, his fictional surrogate. He reveals everyone's flaws without sentimentality, including his own emotional paralysis.
🧠 Ethical Questions
Using real people in fiction opens moral dilemmas:
-
Is it artistic license or betrayal?
-
Hemingway’s depictions are not caricatures, but they are unforgiving.
-
His need for emotional clarity may have come at the cost of real-world relationships.
Some critics argue that Hemingway’s use of roman à clef reflects not only his aesthetic but his psychological need for control—to reduce life to clean lines, to master the mess through narrative.
🌀 Roman à Clef as Processual Mirror
From a Whiteheadian perspective, The Sun Also Rises can be read as a field of prehension: Hemingway is absorbing real relationships, emotional intensities, disappointments, and rituals, and concrescing them into a form that feels meaningful—even if painful.
-
These characters are not just mimetic—they are relational crystallizations of an experience in flux.
-
Each person, each scene, becomes an “actual occasion” in Whitehead’s sense—grasped, transformed, and recreated with aesthetic intensity.
🔍 Summary: Fictionalization as Reality Refinement
-
Jake ≠ Hemingway, but Jake is Hemingway’s stylized presence.
-
Brett ≠ Duff, but Brett allows Hemingway to explore female desire and disillusionment with depth and constraint.
-
Cohn ≠ Loeb, but Cohn gives Hemingway a canvas for examining idealism in a cynical world.
The Sun Also Rises is a novel not just about events—it is about the shape and meaning of events, and how we form those meanings through emotional, aesthetic, and philosophical lenses.
 |
| Philosopher, Mathematician A.N. Whitehead |
VII. Whiteheadian Reading of The Sun Also Rises
🌊 A Processual Lens on Modernist Fiction
Alfred North Whitehead’s process philosophy centers on reality as a web of relational becoming. Nothing is static—everything is in process, constantly being shaped by prior experiences and shaping future ones. When we apply this metaphysical lens to Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, the novel becomes more than a modernist artifact of loss; it becomes a textual concrescence of lived experience, emotion, and social interplay.
“The art of progress is to preserve order amid change and to preserve change amid order.” — Whitehead
This summarizes both Hemingway’s stylistic minimalism and the emotional turbulence beneath his surface structure.
🔁 Eternal Recurrence as Processual Cycle
The novel opens with disillusionment and ends in unresolved longing. Jake and Brett’s final conversation—“Isn’t it pretty to think so?”—suggests a failure of closure. But from a Whiteheadian view, this non-closure is the point. The characters are not stuck in eternal despair; they are actual entities in process, adapting to new realities and new limits.
Rather than redemption, the novel offers ongoing negotiation with meaning, shaped by memory, loss, and possibility.
🔄 Prehensions & Emotional Resonance
Whitehead’s idea of prehension—how each entity grasps, includes, or excludes aspects of prior events—is echoed in Jake Barnes’ introspective narrative style. He reflects, edits, and filters past experiences to make sense of the present.
-
Jake prehends Brett with longing and realism.
-
Brett prehends Pedro Romero as youth and purity—but cannot retain him.
-
Cohn prehends love as possession, which destroys its possibility.
Each character acts on the basis of subjective aims, influenced by pain, culture, memory, and desire. They do not merely live; they concresce meaning from their situations.
⚖️ Displacement, Not Nihilism
Though the novel is saturated with malaise, a Whiteheadian reading helps us move beyond the “lostness” of the generation. It isn’t that life has lost meaning; it’s that meaning is no longer inherited from external structures like church, war, or patriarchy. Instead, meaning is:
-
improvised (as in Jake’s moral restraint),
-
aestheticized (as in bullfighting), or
-
relationally tragic (as in Brett’s desire for connection).
This aligns with Whitehead’s aesthetic cosmology—where beauty emerges through contrast, even tragedy.
🎭 Hemingway’s Style as Process
Hemingway’s Iceberg Theory (what is left unsaid is more important than what is said) parallels Whitehead’s notion that process includes both actualities and potentialities. Hemingway’s spareness does not signify emptiness; it signifies a dynamic field of potential beneath the text.
In this sense, the silences in the novel—the gaps, the absences, the things we “almost know”—become pregnant with becoming. Each pause is a lure toward new interpretation, not a dead end.
🌀 Reconstructing Identity in a Disrupted World
The characters exist within a ruptured moral cosmos. War has destroyed traditional anchors. In Whiteheadian terms, they are caught between:
-
actual worlds (suffering, impotence, betrayal),
-
and possible worlds (beauty, loyalty, love).
The tragedy is that they can imagine what might have been—but cannot inhabit it. Yet even this imagination becomes part of their ongoing self-construction.
Jake’s quiet, persistent dignity, Brett’s self-awareness, and even Cohn’s humiliations—all become part of their process of becoming, their “subjective aim” to endure and define meaning in a shifting terrain.
🧩 The Novel as Actual Entity
From a process metaphysical view, The Sun Also Rises is not merely a representation—it is itself an actual entity, composed of:
-
Emotional intensities
-
Historical realities
-
Stylistic abstractions
-
Relational tensions
It “prehends” Hemingway’s life, the lives of others, the rhythms of language, and the ache of an era, then concresces into a novel that is not finished. Every reader becomes a new occasion in its unfolding process.
✅ Conclusion: A Novel Always Becoming
Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, viewed through a Whiteheadian lens, becomes:
-
Not a static portrait of loss, but a rhythmic meditation on impermanence.
-
Not a closed text, but an open field of becoming.
-
Not just a tragedy of a lost generation, but a revelation of relational endurance in a changing world.
It affirms that the soul of art, like the soul of a person, lies not in certainty, but in attuned vulnerability to the process of life unfolding.
No comments:
Post a Comment